# EN ISO 10042 Aluminium Weld Quality Levels: Acceptance Criteria Guide

Source: https://www.therness.com/blog/en-iso-10042-aluminium-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels/
Language: en

![EN ISO 10042 Aluminium Weld Quality Levels: Acceptance Criteria Guide](https://www.therness.com/assets/images/blog/en-iso-10042-aluminium-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels.webp)

EN ISO 10042 acceptance criteria for aluminium welds: quality levels B, C, D with imperfection tables, selection guide, and monitoring approach for welding.

**Author:** Luca Santoro **Published:** 14 May 2026 **Reading time:** 10 min

- EN ISO 10042
- aluminium welding
- weld quality levels
- weld acceptance criteria
- ISO 5817
- aluminum welding
- EN 1090-3

EN ISO 10042 is the acceptance criteria standard for arc-welded aluminium — the direct structural counterpart of [ISO 5817](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-5817-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels/) for steel. It defines three quality levels (B, C, D), each with specific dimensional limits for every class of weld imperfection. Applying ISO 5817 limits to aluminium welds — or assuming that “the same weld quality standard” applies regardless of base material — is a compliance error with real consequences under EN 1090-3, EN 15085, and aerospace supply chain audits.

This guide covers what EN ISO 10042 requires, how its levels compare side by side, where it diverges from ISO 5817, and how real-time process monitoring with [Therness weld quality systems](https://www.therness.com/products/) supports conformity documentation.

---

## What is EN ISO 10042?

EN ISO 10042 is the ISO standard that grades imperfections in arc-welded aluminium and aluminium-alloy joints into three quality levels — B, C, and D. It is the aluminium counterpart of ISO 5817, which performs the same function for steel, nickel, and titanium welds; neither standard covers both material families.

| Quick fact | Detail |
| --- | --- |
| Designation | EN ISO 10042 (confirm the edition your contract cites) |
| Issuing body | ISO, adopted as EN by CEN |
| Quality levels | B, C, D — see how a [quality level](https://www.therness.com/glossary/quality-level/) is defined and chosen |
| Steel / nickel / titanium counterpart | ISO 5817 |
| Governing execution standard | EN 1090-3 (aluminium structures) |
| Applies only to | Arc-welded joints (GMAW, GTAW, PAW) |

For a one-page scope check — including whether a specific joint falls under this standard or under ISO 5817 — see the [EN ISO 10042 standard entry](https://www.therness.com/standards/iso-10042/).

---

## Scope and applicable processes

EN ISO 10042:2005+A1:2013 covers **arc welding of wrought and cast aluminium and aluminium alloys**, including:

- Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW / MIG)
- Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW / TIG)
- Plasma Arc Welding (PAW)

The standard applies from **0.5 mm thickness** for butt welds and **1.5 mm** for fillet welds, covering sheet, extrusions, and castings across structural, transport, and industrial manufacturing contexts.

Processes **not covered** by EN ISO 10042: friction stir welding (FSW — refer to ISO 25239-5), resistance welding, electron beam welding, and standalone laser welding. For laser-MIG hybrid or laser-arc combinations, supplementary quality requirements agreed between manufacturer and customer are common practice alongside this standard.

---

## The three quality levels

EN ISO 10042 uses the same level notation as ISO 5817:

| Level | Designation | Typical application context |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **B** | Stringent | Safety-critical, fatigue-loaded joints, aerospace, rail CP A/B, EN 1090-3 EXC3/EXC4 |
| **C** | Intermediate | General structural fabrication (EXC2), moderate fatigue loading |
| **D** | Moderate | Non-critical assemblies, static loading only, EN 1090-3 EXC1 |

Level B imposes the smallest permitted imperfection sizes. Level D is the most permissive. The sequence deliberately starts at B — following ISO 5817 convention — to leave room for a future Level A, which has not been published for aluminium arc welding.

**The quality level is specified, not chosen.** EN 1090-3, EN 15085-3, and EN 9100 each define which level applies based on execution class or weld class. The manufacturer must demonstrate conformity to the specified level — not elect the most convenient one.

---

## Acceptance limits: B vs C vs D

The table below summarises the most commonly inspected imperfection types in aluminium arc welds. References are to EN ISO 10042:2005+A1:2013. For thickness-dependent limits, `t` = nominal material thickness; `d` = pore diameter; `h` = height or depth of the imperfection; `b` = weld width.

| Imperfection type | ISO 6520-1 code | Level B | Level C | Level D |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Crack (all types) | 100 | Not permitted | Not permitted | Not permitted |
| Lack of fusion | 401 | Not permitted | Not permitted | Not permitted |
| Incomplete root penetration (full-pen butt) | 4021 | Not permitted | Not permitted | Not permitted |
| Oxide inclusions | 303 | Not permitted | h \<= 0.1t, max 1 mm | h \<= 0.2t, max 2 mm |
| Single gas pore | 2011 | d \<= 0.2 mm or 0.025t | d \<= 0.4 mm or 0.05t | d \<= 0.5 mm or 0.1t |
| Field porosity (projected area) | 2012 | \<= 1% | \<= 2% | \<= 4% |
| Wormhole / tubular pore | 2016 | Not permitted | Not permitted | h \<= 0.2t, max 2 mm |
| Continuous undercut | 5011 | h \<= 0.05t, max 0.5 mm | h \<= 0.1t, max 1 mm | h \<= 0.2t, max 2 mm |
| Overlap (cold lap) | 506 | Not permitted | Not permitted | h \<= 1 mm |
| Linear misalignment (butt) | 507 | h \<= 0.05t, max 2 mm | h \<= 0.1t, max 3 mm | h \<= 0.15t, max 4 mm |
| Excess weld metal (butt, face) | 502 | h \<= 1 mm + 0.1b | h \<= 1 mm + 0.15b | h \<= 1 mm + 0.25b |
| Sagging / burn-through | 509/510 | Not permitted | h \<= 0.1t, max 1 mm | h \<= 0.2t, max 2 mm |
| Crater pipe | 2025 | Not permitted | h \<= 0.05t, max 0.5 mm | h \<= 0.1t, max 1 mm |
| Root concavity | 515 | h \<= 0.05t, max 0.5 mm | h \<= 0.1t, max 1 mm | h \<= 0.2t, max 2 mm |

The values above are indicative reference figures based on EN ISO 10042:2005+A1:2013. Always verify acceptance limits against the current edition of the standard, any overriding customer specification, sector code, or supplementary requirement. Some limits vary with weld type (butt vs fillet) and material thickness sub-range.

---

## EN ISO 10042 vs ISO 5817: the difference in practice

Both share the same B/C/D level letters, but the limits behind them are not interchangeable — treating an aluminium joint’s [lack of fusion](https://www.therness.com/defects/401-lack-of-fusion/) or porosity call as “the same as ISO 5817” is the compliance error the intro warns about.

| Aspect | ISO 5817 (steel, nickel, titanium) | EN ISO 10042 (aluminium) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Oxide inclusions | Folded into general inclusion rows | Dedicated aluminium-specific category, reflecting the Al₂O₃ surface film |
| Porosity limits | Baseline | Tighter for [gas porosity](https://www.therness.com/defects/2011-porosity/), reflecting aluminium’s higher hydrogen pickup |
| Sagging / burn-through | Calibrated for steel’s higher melting point | Calibrated for aluminium’s lower melting point and higher thermal conductivity |
| Governing execution standard | EN 1090-2 | EN 1090-3 |
| Level notation | B, C, D | B, C, D (same letters, different limits) |

The metallurgical reason behind each divergence is below.

---

## Key differences from ISO 5817

EN ISO 10042 and ISO 5817 share the same structural framework — both use levels B, C, D, both reference ISO 6520-1 imperfection codes, and both classify cracks and lack of fusion as non-acceptable at every level. The divergences are material-specific and non-trivial.

### Oxide inclusions

Aluminium forms a tenacious Al₂O₃ oxide film on its surface at room temperature. This film must be removed by mechanical cleaning, chemical etching, or cathodic arc cleaning during GTAW before welding. If inadequately cleaned, or if shielding gas coverage fails, **oxide inclusions** remain trapped in the solidified weld. ISO 10042 includes a dedicated category for oxide inclusions (code 303) that has no direct equivalent in ISO 5817.

At Level B, oxide inclusions are not permitted. At Level C and D, limited inclusions are accepted depending on their depth relative to thickness — but their presence typically signals a process control failure that should be investigated rather than accepted on dimensional grounds alone.

### Tighter porosity limits

Aluminium alloys absorb hydrogen from moisture, lubricants, oxide films, and contaminated filler wire. As the weld pool solidifies, hydrogen comes out of solution as gas pores. Single-pore diameter limits in EN ISO 10042 are **significantly tighter** than the equivalent levels in ISO 5817: a Level B pore limit of d ≤ 0.2 mm compares to d ≤ 0.5 mm in ISO 5817 Level B. Field porosity area limits are also reduced by roughly half.

The tighter limits reflect that:

1. Gas porosity is far more prevalent in aluminium than in structural steel under comparable process conditions.
2. Hydrogen pores can be sub-surface and cluster in ways that are difficult to detect by visual testing alone.
3. Porosity in fatigue-loaded aluminium structures acts as a crack initiation site with a lower threshold than in steel.

### Sagging and burn-through

Aluminium melts at ~660 °C — less than half the solidus temperature of structural steel — and has roughly three times higher thermal conductivity. These properties make sagging (excess root penetration from gravity-driven pool drop) and burn-through significantly more common, especially in thin extrusions and sheet below 3 mm. ISO 10042 treats sagging and burn-through as specific, separately coded imperfections with their own Level B/C/D limits. ISO 5817 includes the same codes but with limits calibrated for materials that do not approach burn-through under normal weld conditions.

### Standard mapping: EN 1090-3, not EN 1090-2

ISO 5817 integrates with **EN 1090-2** (execution of steel structures). EN ISO 10042 integrates with **EN 1090-3** (execution of aluminium structures). A weld drawing for an aluminium structural component must reference EN ISO 10042 quality levels — using ISO 5817 level designations on an aluminium-structure drawing is a normative error that will be flagged in a CE marking or third-party audit.

---

## Selecting the quality level: standard mappings

| Governing code | Execution / weld class | Required EN ISO 10042 level |
| --- | --- | --- |
| EN 1090-3 | EXC1 | D |
| EN 1090-3 | EXC2 | C |
| EN 1090-3 | EXC3 | B |
| EN 1090-3 | EXC4 | B |
| EN 15085-3 | CP A | B + supplementary requirements |
| EN 15085-3 | CP B | B |
| EN 15085-3 | CP C | C |
| EN 15085-3 | CP D | D |
| EN 9100 / AS9100 | — | B (minimum; customer may require supplementary) |
| NADCAP welding | — | B (or customer-defined above B) |

**When no governing code applies**, apply the consequence-of-failure logic from ISO 3834: safety-critical or fatigue-loaded welds → Level B; general structural service → Level C; non-critical, statically loaded assemblies → Level D.

---

## Inspection methods and NDT requirements

Visual testing (VT) per ISO 17637 is mandatory for all three quality levels. Additional NDT methods are specified by the applicable product standard and weld class:

- **Penetrant testing (PT):** ISO 3452-1 — used for surface-breaking defects in aluminium. More reliable than magnetic particle testing, which is not applicable to non-ferromagnetic aluminium.
- **Radiographic testing (RT):** ISO 17636-1 — used for volumetric inspection (porosity, inclusions). Applicable to butt welds; film or digital detector.
- **Ultrasonic testing (UT):** ISO 17640 — applicable to thicker sections (typically above 8 mm); phased array techniques improve coverage for aluminium’s high acoustic attenuation.

Level B welds under EN 1090-3 EXC3/EXC4 and CP A/B welds under EN 15085 typically require 100% NDT coverage across all applicable methods. Level C welds may require partial sampling depending on the joint category.

### Real-time thermal monitoring as a process quality record

Aluminium-specific defects — porosity, oxide inclusions, and sagging — are strongly correlated with **arc parameter deviations** during welding. Hydrogen porosity spikes when arc energy drops below the value needed to drive off surface moisture; oxide inclusions appear when shielding gas coverage fails or pre-cleaning is inadequate; sagging develops when heat input exceeds the material’s thermal tolerance in thin sections ([see real-time thermal imaging of a live weld](https://www.therness.com/videos/real-time-thermal-imaging-welding/)).

[Real-time thermal monitoring for aluminium welding](https://www.therness.com/blog/aluminum-welding-quality-monitoring-thermal-imaging/) captures the thermal signature of each weld pass in-cycle and ties it to weld position coordinates. This supports the **ISO 3834-2 traceability requirement** by providing a continuous process record without adding inspection steps. For high-volume aluminium production — automotive body-in-white panels, EV battery enclosures, rail bogie frames — thermal monitoring reduces the cost of post-weld destructive sampling while building a digital evidence trail that directly supports EN ISO 10042 conformity declarations. A [welding monitoring system built for quality levels B, C, and D](https://www.therness.com/welding-monitoring-system/) can flag a drifting pass before it becomes a rejectable pore, turning each thermal record into a conformity signal rather than just a log.

### Monitor aluminium welds against EN ISO 10042 in real time

Therness thermal monitoring detects arc parameter deviations linked to porosity, oxide inclusions, and sagging before visual inspection. Supports ISO 3834-2 traceability and EN ISO 10042 conformity documentation.

 [Book a demo](https://www.therness.com/contact/)

---

## Standards and further reading

- **EN ISO 10042:2005+A1:2013** — primary reference for aluminium arc weld quality levels
- **[ISO 5817](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-5817-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels/)** — equivalent standard for steel and nickel alloy arc welds
- **[ISO 3834 quality requirements](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-3834-en-1090-audit-checklist-welding-manufacturers/)** — comprehensive, standard, and elementary quality requirements for fusion welding
- **EN 1090-3** — execution of aluminium structures; maps execution classes to EN ISO 10042 levels
- **EN 15085-3** — welding of railway vehicles and components; assigns weld class (CP A–D) quality levels
- **ISO 6520-1** — classification and terminology of imperfections in metallic materials with fusion welding
- **ISO 17637** — visual testing of fusion-welded joints
- **ISO 3452-1** — non-destructive testing: penetrant testing (method applicable to aluminium)

**Therness solution:** [Welding monitoring system](https://www.therness.com/welding-monitoring-system/) — Each weld compared with a reference in the cycle, with anomaly flags and the ISO 3834 / ISO 17635 evidence kept per weld.

Written by **Luca Santoro**  , [founder](https://www.therness.com/author/luca-santoro/)

## Related Therness solution

[AI weld monitoring platformIn-cycle process-drift visibility and durable QC evidence across thermal, visual and parameter signals.](https://www.therness.com/welding-monitoring-system/)

![First page of the Therness guide to choosing an ISO 5817 quality level](https://www.therness.com/assets/images/resource-previews/iso5817-guide-preview.jpg)

Free reference guide 4 pages · PDF · EN

## Choosing and Proving an ISO 5817 Quality Level

The part the standard does not cover: which level to specify, who decides, and what evidence stands up in an audit six months later.

- How to pick B, C or D per joint instead of blanket-specifying the tightest level
- The six findings that cause most visual rejections, and why undercut leads
- The four things an ISO 3834 or EN 1090 auditor actually asks to see

 Download the guide

## Frequently Asked Questions

### What is EN ISO 10042 and how does it differ from ISO 5817?

EN ISO 10042 defines quality levels (B, C, D) for imperfections in arc-welded aluminium and aluminium alloys — the direct counterpart of ISO 5817 for steel. Both share the same level notation but have different acceptance limits and imperfection categories. ISO 10042 includes aluminium-specific discontinuities such as oxide inclusions (from the Al2O3 surface layer) and applies tighter porosity limits than ISO 5817, reflecting aluminium's higher susceptibility to hydrogen-induced gas pores from moisture and oxide contamination.

### What are the three quality levels in EN ISO 10042?

Level B (stringent), Level C (intermediate), and Level D (moderate). Level B is the most demanding, with the smallest tolerated imperfection sizes; Level D is the most permissive. The sequence starts at B rather than A following the same convention as ISO 5817 — leaving space for a stricter Level A that does not yet exist in the standard. Cracks, lack of fusion, and incomplete root penetration are not acceptable at any level.

### Which EN ISO 10042 quality level is required for structural aluminium?

EN 1090-3 (aluminium structural components) maps execution classes to required quality levels: EXC1 requires Level D, EXC2 requires Level C, EXC3 and EXC4 require Level B. For rail vehicles, EN 15085-3 assigns levels by weld class: CP A and CP B require Level B, CP C requires Level C, CP D requires Level D. Aerospace applications per EN 9100 typically require Level B as a minimum and may add supplementary requirements beyond the standard.

### What is the difference between EN ISO 10042 and ISO 5817 in practice?

Both standards use the same B, C, D level notation and the same ISO 6520-1 imperfection numbering, but the limits behind those letters are not interchangeable. EN ISO 10042 treats oxide inclusions as a dedicated aluminium-specific category rather than folding them into general inclusion rows, sets tighter gas-porosity limits, and plugs into EN 1090-3 rather than EN 1090-2. Specifying an ISO 5817 level on an aluminium drawing does not transfer the intended requirement across — pick the standard by parent material first, then read off the level.

### What does EN ISO 10042 cover?

EN ISO 10042 covers quality levels for imperfections in arc-welded joints — GMAW, GTAW, and PAW only — in wrought and cast aluminium and aluminium alloys, from 0.5 mm thickness for butt welds. It does not cover friction stir welding, resistance welding, electron beam welding, or standalone laser welding — those fall under a process-specific standard instead.

### Can I apply ISO 5817 quality levels to aluminium welds instead of EN ISO 10042?

No. ISO 5817 is calibrated for steel, nickel, and titanium: it folds oxide inclusions into general inclusion rows rather than treating them as a dedicated aluminium-specific category, and its porosity limits are looser than aluminium's higher hydrogen pickup requires. Using ISO 5817 on an aluminium joint under EN 1090-3, EN 15085-3, or an aerospace quality system is treated as a normative error in a CE marking or third-party audit, not an acceptable like-for-like substitution.

### Share this article

[LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.therness.com%2Fblog%2Fen-iso-10042-aluminium-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels%2F) [X / Twitter](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.therness.com%2Fblog%2Fen-iso-10042-aluminium-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels%2F&text=EN%20ISO%2010042%20Aluminium%20Weld%20Quality%20Levels%3A%20Acceptance%20Criteria%20Guide) Email

## Related articles

![ISO 5817 vs ASME & AWS: Weld Acceptance Criteria Compared](https://www.therness.com/assets/images/blog/iso-5817-vs-asme-aws-weld-acceptance-criteria-differences.webp)

### ISO 5817 vs ASME & AWS: Weld Acceptance Criteria Compared

How EN ISO 5817 quality levels differ from ASME code acceptance criteria and AWS D1.1: philosophy, structure, inspection extent, and how dual-compliance.

[ISO 5817 vs ASME & AWS: Weld Acceptance Criteria Compared](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-5817-vs-asme-aws-weld-acceptance-criteria-differences/)

![ISO 5817 Level B vs C vs D: Weld Quality Comparison 2026](https://www.therness.com/assets/images/blog/iso-5817-level-b-vs-c-vs-d-weld-quality-comparison.webp)

### ISO 5817 Level B vs C vs D: Weld Quality Comparison 2026

ISO 5817 levels B, C, and D explained side by side — acceptance limits, imperfection tables, decision criteria, and when to use each quality level.

[ISO 5817 Level B vs C vs D: Weld Quality Comparison 2026](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-5817-level-b-vs-c-vs-d-weld-quality-comparison/)

![ISO 5817: which quality level B, C or D your weld must meet](https://www.therness.com/assets/images/blog/iso-5817/hero-iso-5817.webp)

### ISO 5817: which quality level B, C or D your weld must meet

ISO 5817 weld quality levels B, C and D: which one to specify, the defect limits behind each, and the inspection checklist that proves it.

[ISO 5817: which quality level B, C or D your weld must meet](https://www.therness.com/blog/iso-5817-weld-acceptance-criteria-quality-levels/)
