# Lack of sidewall fusion (ISO 6520-1 ref. 4011): causes and detection

Source: https://www.therness.com/defects/4011-sidewall-lack-of-fusion/
Language: en

ISO 6520-1 group 4 · Lack of fusion and penetration

ISO 6520-1 reference 4011 is a planar imperfection at the joint bevel face that visual inspection cannot see. Cause matrix, why ultrasonic testing leads detection, and the standards that govern acceptance.

ISO 6520-1 reference

4011

Group

4 — Lack of fusion and penetration

Also called

Sidewall lack of fusion, Incomplete sidewall fusion, Cold lap at the bevel

Full guide

[Sidewall lack of fusion: the long-form guide](https://www.therness.com/blog/lack-of-fusion-welding-causes-detection-acceptance-criteria/)

This page is the reference card — causes, detection and where acceptance is defined. The guide covers the subject in depth.

Reference 4011 narrows reference 401 to one specific location: the sidewall, the bevel face of the joint rather than the previous run. It is the form of lack of fusion most associated with narrow-groove and mechanised welding, where a tighter bevel saves filler metal and time — and restricts the exact arc access the sidewall needs.

The cause matrix asks one question from different angles: did the arc reach the bevel face with enough energy and dwell time to fuse it. A narrow groove restricts access geometrically. High travel speed and low arc energy restrict it thermally. A torch aimed at the pool instead of the sidewall restricts it by technique. Any one produces the same buried, planar result.

Pairing arc energy and travel speed records with a pool camera view of sidewall wetting does not confirm fusion after the fact, but shows whether the conditions that produce 4011 were present on the pass ultrasonic testing will later have to find them on.

See reference 401, [lack of fusion](https://www.therness.com/defects/401-lack-of-fusion/), in general; reference 4013, [lack of root fusion](https://www.therness.com/defects/4013-root-lack-of-fusion/), the sibling at the other end of the joint; and reference 402, [lack of penetration](https://www.therness.com/defects/402-lack-of-penetration/).

## Typical causes

What produces sidewall lack of fusion, the mechanism, and the control that removes it

| Cause | Mechanism | Control |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Arc not aimed at the bevel face | A torch, gun or weave pattern centred on the pool rather than dwelling on the sidewall leaves the bevel face itself below fusion temperature even while the pool looks normal. | Qualify torch angle and weave pattern for the joint geometry and verify positioning in the cell, not only on the procedure sheet. |
| Groove angle too narrow for the process | A narrow bevel, common in narrow-gap and mechanised welding for cost, restricts arc access to the sidewall at any parameter setting. | Treat repeated sidewall findings on one joint design as a design or access problem, not an operator problem. |
| Travel speed too high on fill passes | The pool advances faster than it can wet the sidewall, laying metal over a bevel face that never reached fusion temperature. | Measure travel speed rather than estimating it from bead appearance; on mechanised work it is the parameter most likely to drift with fixturing. |
| Arc energy below the qualified window | Insufficient energy per unit length fails to melt the bevel face before the adjacent pool solidifies against it. | Compute arc energy from measured current, voltage and travel speed per pass instead of nominal figures. |
| Mill scale or oxide left on the bevel face | A surface film prevents metallurgical bonding at the sidewall even when the thermal conditions are otherwise correct. | Enforce joint-face cleaning as a hold point ahead of each pass and record that it happened. |

## Detection: which route finds it

The column that matters most is the last one. An inspection family marked as not finding this imperfection will not find it however carefully it is applied, and planning around that is cheaper than discovering it during a final examination.

Detection routes for sidewall lack of fusion, and what each one can and cannot see

| Family | Method | Capability | What it sees |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Visual | Visual testing to ISO 17637 | Does not find it | The imperfection sits at the bevel face under the cap. A visually acceptable bead gives no information about sidewall bonding underneath it. |
| Thermal | In-process infrared thermography | Supporting signal | Sees the conditions that produce it — low arc energy, high travel speed, an arc not dwelling on the sidewall — rather than the imperfection itself. |
| Camera | High-speed weld pool imaging | Supporting signal | Shows whether the pool is actually wetting the bevel face and where the arc is aimed relative to it, while the run is being made. |
| NDT | Ultrasonic and phased array testing to ISO 17640 and ISO 13588 | Primary route | The leading route for a planar imperfection at a known geometric location. Radiography can miss one entirely when the plane is unfavourable to the beam. |

## Where acceptance is defined

Therness pages never reproduce a standard's acceptance values: those tables are copyrighted and belong in the copy you hold. What follows is the pointer — which document governs, and which part of it to open.

Documents that set the acceptance criteria, and the clause topic to read

| Standard | Clause topic | Note |
| --- | --- | --- |
| ISO 5817 | Quality levels for planar imperfections, indexed by ISO 6520-1 reference number | Sidewall lack of fusion is treated under the same strict planar-imperfection rows as the parent reference 401. |
| ISO 11666 | Ultrasonic acceptance levels for welds, paired with the quality level chosen | The examination standard and the quality-level standard are selected together, not independently. |
| ASME BPVC Section VIII | Pressure vessel acceptance, with examination methods in Section V | Read the construction code, not the qualification code, for the limit. |

## Standards that govern this imperfection

- [ISO 5817](https://www.therness.com/standards/iso-5817/)Does ISO 5817 govern your joint? Scope decision flow for the steel, nickel and titanium quality-level standard, the codes it is read with, and the records that evidence conformity.
- [ISO 6520-1](https://www.therness.com/standards/iso-6520-1/)Does ISO 6520-1 name the imperfection you are looking at? Scope decision flow for the fusion-welding classification standard, the six groups it defines, and the standards read alongside it.
- [ISO 17640](https://www.therness.com/standards/iso-17640/)Does ISO 17640 govern the ultrasonic examination in front of you? Scope decision flow for the manual UT standard, the codes it is read with, and the records that support the result.

## Imperfections found alongside it

- [Incomplete fusion (ref. 401)](https://www.therness.com/defects/401-lack-of-fusion/)Lack of fusion and penetration — ISO 6520-1 group 4.
- [Root lack of fusion (ref. 4013)](https://www.therness.com/defects/4013-root-lack-of-fusion/)Lack of fusion and penetration — ISO 6520-1 group 4.
- [Incomplete penetration (ref. 402)](https://www.therness.com/defects/402-lack-of-penetration/)Lack of fusion and penetration — ISO 6520-1 group 4.

## Terms used on this page

[Heat input](https://www.therness.com/glossary/heat-input/)

Heat input is the energy delivered to a joint per unit length of weld, calculated from arc voltage, welding current and travel speed and multiplied by the thermal efficiency factor of the process.

## Where this imperfection dominates

Pressure equipment and process plant

### [Weld monitoring for pressure vessels](https://www.therness.com/applications/pressure-vessels/)

Thick-section, multi-pass, code-governed welding. The codes that apply, the four monitoring pain points that cost pressure-vessel fabricators most, and which Therness signal addresses each.

## See the condition, not the consequence

Most weld imperfections are produced by conditions that exist while the arc is running. Therness records those conditions on every weld, so a suspect run is known on the shift that made it rather than in a batch report.

[Book a technical call](https://www.therness.com/contact/) [See the thermal weld camera](https://www.therness.com/products/heatcam-ir-c/)
