Discover HeatCore AI

ISO 6520-1 group 5 · Imperfect shape and dimension

Excessive convexity (ISO 6520-1 ref. 503): causes and detection

ISO 6520-1 reference 503 covers excessive convexity, a fillet weld face bulging past its theoretical flat profile. Cause matrix, why the extra metal outside that profile buys no throat, and where acceptance is set.

ISO 6520-1 reference
503
Group
5 — Imperfect shape and dimension
Also called
Excessive convexity, Convex fillet weld

Excessive convexity is what happens when a fillet weld gets more filler than the joint geometry needs and that excess has nowhere to go but outward. A fillet’s design throat is calculated from the theoretical flat face between its two toes — the geometry behind the throat-thickness relationship — and metal built past that face sits outside the triangle the calculation assumes. It looks generous. It is not bigger.

That is why the imperfection is worth naming apart from excess weld metal: both are over-fill, but a fillet’s capacity is set by throat, not by how much metal sits on top of it, so convexity buys nothing structurally while still costing filler and, on a steep enough transition into the plate, a stress concentration at the weld toe.

The cause matrix runs in two directions — too much filler for the travel speed, or too little heat for the pool to wet the toes it already has — so a fillet weld size calculator run against the specified leg before welding is a faster check than a profile gauge after: it flags a parameter set that will over-deposit or under-wet before the first pass is struck.

Typical causes

What produces excessive convexity, the mechanism, and the control that removes it
CauseMechanismControl
Wire feed speed or current too high for the travel speed and joint sizeMore filler is deposited per unit length than the theoretical flat-face triangle needs, and the excess builds the face out past that profile.Measure wire feed speed and current per pass against the qualified fillet size rather than judging a full-looking bead by eye.
Travel speed too slow for the deposition rateThe pool has more time to accumulate metal at a point before the arc moves on, producing the same bulging profile even at a correctly set wire feed speed.Record travel speed per pass; on manual fillet welding it is the parameter most likely to drift.
Welding current too low, or heat input insufficient for the jointA cold pool does not spread to the toes before it starts to freeze, so it piles up in the middle and stands proud — convex from too little heat, not too much metal.Raise arc energy or reduce wire feed to match it, and check the toes are wetted, not just bead height.

Detection: which route finds it

The column that matters most is the last one. An inspection family marked as not finding this imperfection will not find it however carefully it is applied, and planning around that is cheaper than discovering it during a final examination.

Detection routes for excessive convexity, and what each one can and cannot see
FamilyMethodCapabilityWhat it sees
VisualVisual testing to ISO 17637, with a fillet weld profile gaugePrimary routeThe imperfection is surface geometry, so a gauge reading the face against the theoretical flat profile between the two toes is the intended check.
ThermalIn-process infrared thermographySupporting signalA pass running outside the qualified thermal window shows up before the bead is measured.
CameraWeld pool imagingSupporting signalShows the pool building height on the face rather than flowing into the root while the run is happening, when travel speed can still be corrected.
NDTVolumetric NDT (radiographic or ultrasonic testing)Does not find itExcessive convexity is external profile, not a subsurface flaw; volumetric NDT has nothing to report on a face proud of its theoretical shape.

Where acceptance is defined

Therness pages never reproduce a standard's acceptance values: those tables are copyrighted and belong in the copy you hold. What follows is the pointer — which document governs, and which part of it to open.

Documents that set the acceptance criteria, and the clause topic to read
StandardClause topicNote
ISO 5817Quality levels for fillet weld profile, including excess convexityStated against the fillet's own leg length, not as a fixed height. Read it in the standard.
AWS D1.1Fillet weld profile acceptance for structural connectionsSits alongside, not instead of, the minimum fillet size the connection design requires.

Questions about excessive convexity

Does excessive convexity make a fillet weld stronger?

No. The extra metal sits outside the flat-face triangle the design throat is calculated from, adding weight and cost without adding load-carrying throat.

Is excessive convexity the same as excess weld metal?

Close relatives, not the same row. Excess weld metal (ref. 502) is butt-weld reinforcement; excessive convexity is the fillet-weld version, assessed against the fillet's own flat-face profile.

Can a convex fillet fail a profile check at the correct leg length?

Yes. Leg length and face convexity are measured differently, and a leg-only gauge misses a face bulging past the flat profile between the toes.

See the condition, not the consequence

Most weld imperfections are produced by conditions that exist while the arc is running. Therness records those conditions on every weld, so a suspect run is known on the shift that made it rather than in a batch report.

Progetto cofinanziato nell'ambito del PR Piemonte FSE+ 2021-2027,
Priorità I, Obiettivo Specifico a), Azione 4 – "Sostegno alla nascita delle start up"