# Incompletely filled groove (ISO 6520-1 ref. 511): causes and detection

Source: https://www.therness.com/defects/511-incompletely-filled-groove/
Language: en

ISO 6520-1 group 5 · Imperfect shape and dimension

ISO 6520-1 reference 511 covers incompletely filled groove, a cap or fill pass that stops short of the parent-metal surface. Cause matrix, why a profile gauge settles it, and the standards that set the acceptance limit.

ISO 6520-1 reference

511

Group

5 — Imperfect shape and dimension

Also called

Incompletely filled groove, Underfill, Insufficiently filled groove

Incompletely filled groove is what a cap or fill pass leaves behind when it ends before the joint reaches the parent-metal surface: a shallow trough along part or all of the weld length instead of a flush or proud profile. It sits at the opposite end of the same scale as [excess weld metal](https://www.therness.com/defects/502-excess-weld-metal/) — both are decided entirely by how much filler arrived relative to the groove volume, in opposite directions.

Because the shortfall removes metal that was supposed to be there, it raises the same practical question as [root concavity](https://www.therness.com/defects/515-root-concavity/): whether the joint still delivers its design throat thickness where the pass ran light. A weld that reads acceptable end to end can still fail a profile gauge at one short stretch, which is why the finding is checked along the full length rather than sampled.

The cause matrix is almost entirely a deposition-rate problem — current, wire feed speed and travel speed relative to each other on the final pass — all of it measurable on the same weld pool camera and parameter log that would also catch an excess weld metal drift in the other direction.

## Typical causes

What produces incompletely filled groove, the mechanism, and the control that removes it

| Cause | Mechanism | Control |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Current or wire feed speed below the qualified window on the cap pass | Less filler arrives than the groove volume needs, and the cap freezes short of the plate surface. | Check current and wire feed speed on the final pass against the WPS, not the finished look of the bead. |
| Travel speed too high on the fill or cap pass | The arc advances faster than the pool can deposit enough metal to reach the plate surface. | Log travel speed per pass; a rushed cap is the most common route to this finding. |
| Joint preparation wider than the procedure assumes | A bevel or root gap outside tolerance increases the volume the parameter set was never sized to fill. | Verify prep dimensions against the WPS before welding; treat a recurring shortfall as a fit-up problem. |

## Detection: which route finds it

The column that matters most is the last one. An inspection family marked as not finding this imperfection will not find it however carefully it is applied, and planning around that is cheaper than discovering it during a final examination.

Detection routes for incompletely filled groove, and what each one can and cannot see

| Family | Method | Capability | What it sees |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Visual | Visual testing to ISO 17637, with weld profile gauges | Primary route | A profile gauge settles directly whether the groove reaches the parent surface once the weld is finished. |
| Thermal | In-process infrared thermography | Supporting signal | A cap pass running fast or cool for the window shows in the cooling footprint before the profile is measured. |
| Camera | High-speed weld pool imaging | Supporting signal | Shows the pool failing to bring the groove level with the plate while the pass can still be corrected. |
| NDT | Radiographic and ultrasonic testing to ISO 17636 and ISO 17640 | Limited | Radiography reads the local thickness loss as a density change, but a profile gauge settles the fill depth directly, so volumetric NDT adds little beyond what visual testing already gives. |

## Where acceptance is defined

Therness pages never reproduce a standard's acceptance values: those tables are copyrighted and belong in the copy you hold. What follows is the pointer — which document governs, and which part of it to open.

Documents that set the acceptance criteria, and the clause topic to read

| Standard | Clause topic | Note |
| --- | --- | --- |
| ISO 5817 | Quality levels for imperfect shape and dimension, indexed by ISO 6520-1 reference number | Incompletely filled groove has its own fill criterion, distinct from the reinforcement limit for excess weld metal. |
| AWS D1.1 | Visual acceptance for weld profile on structural steel, where the term used is underfill | AWS terminology differs from ISO 6520-1's; confirm the definition before applying a cited limit. |

## Standards that govern this imperfection

- [ISO 5817](https://www.therness.com/standards/iso-5817/)Does ISO 5817 govern your joint? Scope decision flow for the steel, nickel and titanium quality-level standard, the codes it is read with, and the records that evidence conformity.
- [AWS D1.1](https://www.therness.com/standards/aws-d1-1/)Visual acceptance for weld profile on structural steel, where the term used is underfill

## Imperfections found alongside it

- [Excess reinforcement (ref. 502)](https://www.therness.com/defects/502-excess-weld-metal/)Imperfect shape and dimension — ISO 6520-1 group 5.
- [Root concavity (ref. 515)](https://www.therness.com/defects/515-root-concavity/)Imperfect shape and dimension — ISO 6520-1 group 5.

## Terms used on this page

[Throat thickness](https://www.therness.com/glossary/throat-thickness/)

Throat thickness is the shortest distance from the root of a fillet weld to its face, the internal dimension used in structural calculations rather than the leg length shown on a drawing.

## Where this imperfection dominates

Pipeline construction — oil, gas and product transportation

### [Weld monitoring for pipeline construction](https://www.therness.com/applications/pipeline/)

Cross-country and plant piping welded under API 1104 and the ASME B31 transportation codes. The four monitoring pain points that cost pipeline contractors most, and which Therness signal addresses each.

## Questions about incompletely filled groove

### Is incompletely filled groove the same as undercut?

No. Undercut is a groove melted into the parent metal at the toe by the arc; incompletely filled groove is a filler shortfall on the weld side of the surface, settled with a profile gauge rather than a visual guess.

### Does the finding reduce the design throat thickness?

Yes, along the affected length. A pass that ends short of the parent surface removes exactly that much metal from the section the design assumed.

### Which inspection route actually finds it?

Visual testing with a weld profile gauge to ISO 17637 settles it directly; radiography reads the same shortfall as a density change but adds little a gauge does not already give.

## See the condition, not the consequence

Most weld imperfections are produced by conditions that exist while the arc is running. Therness records those conditions on every weld, so a suspect run is known on the shift that made it rather than in a batch report.

[Book a technical call](https://www.therness.com/contact/) [See the thermal weld camera](https://www.therness.com/products/heatcam-ir-c/)
